Out of control prosecutors not only found in the US

Are Seismologists Responsible for People’s Deaths in an Earthquake?
[Via 80beats]

What’s the News: No one can predict earthquakes. But six seismologists and a government official are being tried for manslaughter in the deaths of more than 300 people in the 2009 tremblor in L’Aquila, Italy. The city’s public prosecutor says the scientists downplayed the possibility of a quake to an extent that townsfolk did not take precautions that could have saved their lives. A judge has just set the trial to begin on September 20.

What’s the Context:

The case, which was brought in 2010, hinges on the statements of Bernardo De Bernardinis of Italy’s Civil Protection Agency at a press conference a week before the quake. His agency had asked the scientists to convene and discuss whether the increasing seismic activity in the area might indicate a risk of a major quake. At the subsequent press conference, De Bernardinis, who is being tried along with the scientists, told the crowd, “The scientific community tells me there is no danger, because there is an ongoing discharge of energy. The situation looks favorable.” (via Nature News) People say that as a result of this reassurance, they didn’t leave …


Even though the minutes of the meeting do not appear to support what the prosecutor is trying to take to trial. These 6 scientists could face up to 12 years in prison.

At least we are not putting scientists into jail. Yet.

One thought on “Out of control prosecutors not only found in the US

Comments are closed.