by Francisco Antunes
California Town’s School Board Wants Politically “Balanced” Curriculum On Climate Change
[Via DeSmogBlog - Clearing the PR Pollution that Clouds Climate Science]
And the headdesk moment of the week goes to Los Alamitos Unified School District, who recently decided that teachers in the school district would have to prove that their curricula have political balance when teaching controversial subjects, including global warming. Reminiscent of the creation of the universe debacles, teachers will now be required to teach “opposing views” because conservative board members are “concerned that ‘liberal’ faculty members could skew lessons on global warming”, according to
local news coverage.
This could potentially become a dangerous trend, considering that several other districts, including the Texas board of education and South Dakota public schools, have taken similar views as well. It might be okay to teach climate skepticism if it indeed was taught and identified as climate misinformation that industries deliberately use to confuse the public, not as just a “dissenting opinion”. However this doesn’t appear to be the case here. Just listen to what one of the school board members has to say:
[More]
Think about all the scientific theories that are obviously kept out of the curriculum for political reasons.
The Phlogiston theory to explain combustion. Using miasmas to explain disease. The luminiferous aether to explain the propagation of light.
So many physics, chemistry and biology lectures provide such unbalanced views. If it was good enough for Aristotle or Ptolemy, it should be good enough for our students. Perhaps if we examined the bumps on their heads we would know which ones were smart or not.
As one of the board members stated, he wants his political views to be represented in the material that is being taught. Because apparently there is a liberal or conservative reason for why the sun shines or the tides rise.
As an example, while most of us were taught the apparently liberal position that the moon causes the tides, Bill O’Reilly provides the conservative reasons.
I know, this is all hyperbole but since the liberals get tarred with the craziest members of their side, I think the conservatives should be tarred with their craziest.
And O’Reilly, the school board administrator and others – such as the Texas Board of Education – are about as crazy as can be.
Science is about trying to create models that come the closest to describing the world around us. Teach different models because neither does an adequate job or one explains things the other does not.
But never teach different models for political reasons. And never state that your political view must be represented.
I think we have a better example than bad teachers for why the school system is so screwed up – the screwed up school boards putting their political beliefs – both conservative and liberal – over the education of students.
Like this:
Be the first to like this post.