by sam_churchill
Gizmodo Reviews the Samsung Galaxy Tab
[Via Daring Fireball]
Scathing review overall (“a pocketable train wreck”, “this thing is just a mess”), but he does say battery life was good.
[More]
And this is from an outfit that has, a best, a tempestuous relationship with Apple. Man, they hit the overall usability a lot. For example, the apps are just scaled up so there is no real advantage over what content the phones provide. Why get a bigger ‘phone’? The larger screen provides no inherent advantage.
How about data input:
There is no way to not feel like a total dorkface while typing on this thing. In portrait, it’s like tapping on a massive, nerdy phone. In landscape, it’s just dumb. You still have to thumb type, only you’re stretching out further, and text entry swallows up the entire screen. Swype might be dandy on a phone, but on a seven-inch screen it doesn’t work so well—you have to travel a lot further to sketch out words. In other words, you get the worst of a phone’s input problems—amplified.
Perhaps having an operating system tuned to the form factor would have helped. In addition, the lack of innovation, should make the ears of lawyers prick up:
In the places where Samsung tries to make the Tab feel more like a tablet than a big phone, it’s not afraid to borrow liberally from what Apple’s done on the iPad. The music app (a huge improvement over the standard Android player) bears an uncanny resemblance to the iPad’s iPod app, while the faux-realness of the Calendar, Contacts and Memo apps feel like Chinatown knockoffs of Cupertino software.
It proves the wisdom of Steve Job’s and the folly of Adobe:
The browser is miserable, at least when Flash is enabled. It goes catatonic, scrolling is laggy, and it can get laughably bad. When better browsing is half the reason to go for a larger screen, that’s insanity.
The 900 or so comments are also quite illuminating. I would not expect the Galaxy Tab to do much this Christmas if this is the general view.
In fact, for me, the killer is having to get a contract. I only deal with the wireless companies because I have to for an iPhone but I really do not want to need them for other stuff.
Like this:
Be the first to like this post.