by acbo
Science in school is not just teaching facts
[Via Butterflies and Wheels]
Science lessons should equip students with critical thinking skills, the most important of which is to ask for evidence for truth-claims.
[More]
I discussed a recent poll that revealed that the British have a much firer grasp of facts than Americans. Here is a nice article demonstrating why.
In Britain, when a science teacher honestly answers the question “Do you believe in God, sir?” by stating “No, I don’t” he can then discuss his purpose is to teach his students to rationally examine the world around them. He can also write an article where he states things like “The truth is that all science teachers must deal with the fact that, if they are teaching science properly, their lessons will necessarily challenge the religious beliefs of some of their students” or “If my colleagues and I do our jobs properly, our students should go away with a story about the history of life and the universe that is far richer, far grander and far more detailed than that presented in any religious text.”
Most likely any teacher who made those same statements in America would be looking for a new job. There might even be lawsuits.
So is it any wonder that Americans do so poorly on any question of science that might impact their religious beliefs in any way? He states exactly why science education in America is so ineffective,
Science lessons should equip students with critical thinking skills, the most important of which is to ask for evidence for claims about “truth”. If we’ve succeeded in teaching these skills, it’s inevitable that some of our religious students will ask “what is the proof for the existence of a god?” and it’s inevitable that some of these students will not be happy with the stock religious answers to this question.
Critical thinking skills are anathema to most religions. The ideal in Britain is something large groups in America work directly against.
It is a wonder that anyone becomes a scientist in America having to endure this approach to education.
Like this:
Be the first to like this post.