by Alan Light
Review of James Cameron’s Avatar, An Ecological and Evolutionary Allegory
[Via Evo.Sphere]
Introduction
[Warning: this essay contains many spoilers. Please see Avatar before reading.]
James Cameron’s Avatar is the feel-good movie of the decade for biophiles and Gaians. The movie is one long, consciously realized allegory about the human love and need for nature. To accomplish the allegorical story, the film uses specific ecological and evolutionary hypotheses about the nature of life and humanity’s relationship to nature. An allegory conveys non-literal meanings, teaches lessons, and communicates messages by means of symbolic figures, actions, and representation. An allegory is an extended metaphor or series of metaphors, and an artistic allegory (as contrasted with a literary allegory) uses visual (rather than verbal) symbolic representation to accomplish these tasks.
A literary metaphor asserts that two usually different things are the same (“all the world’s a stage”; “With cat-like tread, upon our prey we steal”); it uses a word or phrase to invoke a direct similarity between the word or phrase used and the nominally dissimilar thing described. Visual metaphors do the same: they equate two different things (an actor striding across a stage and holding his arms out to form a world; pirates loudly stomping across a stage to pursue burglary while claiming they are quiet as cats to hilarious effect). Visual metaphors in the service of allegory use visual imagery to evoke physical and emotional similarities between the images depicted on stage or screen and the nominally dissimilar objects, actions, places, and people they portray.
Avatar is continuously filled with such visual metaphors that creates its allegory, which makes it an exceedingly rich and artful movie. Movies are supposed to entertain at a minimum, but I appreciate films that rise about mere entertainment and become art, and I appreciate even more movies that use their art to communicate deeply-felt emotional and moral truths about humans and nature through cinematic allegory. The fact that Avatar is so popular demonstrates that it has accomplished this rare feat, despite the usual film-goers lack of comprehension about what they are viewing beyond the superficial fantasy, romance, and shooting, justifiably giving James Cameron some well-earned acclaim and my grateful thanks.
Despite this success, the explanation of what precisely Cameron intended his movie to accomplish has remained elusive. Movie critics and reviewers have examined Avatar from many different themes and points of view but have continued, I believe, to miss the point. The movie is not complex, but because it is an allegory, Avatar’s ultimate message is not literal, and because it uses multiple visual, cinematic metaphors that are unfamiliar to mainstream movie critics and reviewers, interpreting the metaphors and allegory has proven difficult for them and and finding the film’s meaning has proven elusive. Critics and reviewers must use their intelligence and interpretive abilities to discern a film’s meaning. Doing this requires specific background knowledge on which to base an analysis and interpretation, and their lack of this background knowledge explains why so many have failed to understand Avatar. This essay explains what has happened and why this is the case. In a word, their ignorance of biology and religion has caused their interpretations to fail.
[More]
This is a well thought out discussion of the movie. I have mentioned a few of my ideas earlier. Everyone talks about Jake as the hero and the saviour of the Na’vi.
But one of the important aspects of the movie for me is that Jake failed. His approach lost and was going down in flames. All his flying fighters were gone. The infantry and cavalry had failed. The bomber was seconds away from its mission.
The scientist, Grace Augustine, is the reason that Jake and the Na’vi win. Without her, the corporate guys win.
This is because in her death, she merged her consciousness with the ‘planetary’ consciousness. In essence, the whole world became an avatar of Grace
The planet and ecology, Gaia as mentioned in the article, always had the ability to drive off the humans. But it did not recognize them as outsiders but as part of the normal ecology. So it took no action against them
But when Grace entered the consciousness of the planet, she was able to inform it of what was really going on. This is made clear when Jake ‘talks’ with the tree the might before battle. He explicitly tells the planet to look for Grace and listen to her.
Without the sacrifice of Grace, the planet would not have known that it had to combat the humans. Once it did, it mobilized its forces to accomplish the victory.
Without the planet’s help, Jake and the Na’vi would not have won. Without Grace, the planet would not have helped.
Jake was a catalyst but Grace was the spark that resulted in a win for the moon, Pandora, and its inhabitants